College Football Overtime Rules Explained Simply

Background: Why College Football Has Different Overtime Rules

College football’s overtime system was introduced in 1996 to replace the old tie rule. Before that, games could end in a tie, which many fans and coaches found unsatisfying. The NCAA wanted a system that would determine a winner while keeping the game safe and not dragging on for hours. The result is a unique format that differs from the NFL’s sudden-death overtime and from high school rules in many states.

The key difference from the NFL is that in college, both teams get a chance to score, so the team that wins the coin toss doesn’t have an automatic advantage. This makes the overtime more about execution than about winning a coin flip.

How College Football Overtime Works

Here is the basic structure of a college football overtime period:

Coin toss determines possession – Before the first overtime, the referee conducts a coin toss. The visiting team calls the toss. The winner chooses whether to be on offense or defense first, or which end of the field to defend. The loser gets the other choice.
Ball placed at the 25-yard line – The offensive team starts a drive from the opponent’s 25-yard line. This is not a kickoff; it’s a scrimmage down. The offense has four downs to score a touchdown or kick a field goal.
First team runs its possession – The offense tries to score. If they score a touchdown, they can attempt a one-point or two-point conversion. If they kick a field goal, they get three points. If they turn the ball over on downs or commit a turnover, their possession ends.
Second team runs its possession – The other team then gets the same opportunity from the same spot. If they score more points than the first team, they win immediately. If they score fewer, they lose. If the score is tied after both possessions, the game goes to another overtime.
Second overtime rules change – In the second overtime, teams must attempt a two-point conversion after a touchdown (no extra point kick). Also, after the second overtime, if the game is still tied, the third overtime and beyond become a series of two-point conversion attempts only, not full possessions.
Third overtime and beyond – Starting with the third overtime, each team runs a play from the 3-yard line for a two-point conversion. They do not get a first down or a new set of downs; it’s one play. The team that converts more times wins. If still tied, they keep going, alternating attempts.

This format is designed to end games relatively quickly while still giving both teams a fair chance. The move to two-point conversions after the second overtime speeds up the process and adds drama.

What to Check First: The Overtime Coin Toss

Before the first overtime, the referee conducts a coin toss at midfield. The visiting team calls the toss. The winner chooses one of two options:

To be on offense or defense first
Which end of the field to defend

The loser gets the remaining choice. Many teams choose to be on defense first, hoping to get a stop and then win with a field goal or touchdown. But some prefer offense to set the tone. There’s no universal right answer; it depends on the team’s strengths and the game situation.

After the first overtime, if a second overtime is needed, the team that lost the first coin toss gets to make the choice for the second overtime. This alternates each overtime period, ensuring fairness.

Common Problems and Misconceptions

One common misconception is that the team that wins the coin toss automatically has an advantage. In reality, because both teams get a possession, the advantage is minimal. Another misconception is that a team can win with a field goal on the first possession and then the other team must go for a touchdown. That’s not true – the second team can also kick a field goal to tie and force another overtime.

Another issue is the “two-point conversion” rule. Some fans think it applies only in the third overtime, but it actually starts in the second overtime. Also, in the second overtime, if a team scores a touchdown, they must go for two points – they cannot kick an extra point. This rule was added to make the game end sooner.

Finally, some people confuse college overtime with NFL overtime. In the NFL, it’s sudden death – the first team to score wins, unless it’s a field goal on the first possession, then the other team gets a chance. In college, both teams always get a possession, unless the defense scores a touchdown (a pick-six or fumble recovery) – in that case, the game ends immediately because the defense has scored more points than the offense can match.

Comparisons: College vs. NFL Overtime

Here’s a quick comparison to highlight the differences:

Starting position: College starts at the 25-yard line; NFL starts at the 25-yard line (since 2012, but with different rules).
Possession: College gives both teams a possession; NFL uses sudden death (unless the first team only gets a field goal, then the other team gets a possession).
Extra points: College allows a one-point kick in the first overtime, but mandates two-point conversions from the second overtime onward; NFL always allows a one-point kick.
End of game: College can end on a defensive score (interception or fumble return) immediately; NFL also ends on any score, but the other team gets a possession if it’s a field goal on the first drive.

These differences make college overtime more team-friendly and often more exciting because both offenses get a chance.

Safety and Strategy in Overtime

Overtime can be physically demanding, especially if it goes to multiple periods. Players are already tired from a full game, and the added plays increase fatigue and injury risk. Coaches often manage this by rotating players more, especially on defense. The NCAA has rules about the number of timeouts and the length of breaks between periods, but the main safety concern is fatigue.

Strategy-wise, teams often simplify their playcalls in overtime. They might rely on their best running back or a specific passing route. The two-point conversion phase is particularly strategic – it’s essentially a short-yardage play, so teams often have a few go-to plays for that situation.

Another safety aspect is the field position. Starting at the 25-yard line means the offense is in field goal range, so defenses must be careful not to give up big plays. But it also means the offense might be more aggressive, going for a touchdown rather than settling for a field goal.

Alternatives and Variations

Some high school leagues use a similar overtime format, but many use a variation where the ball is placed at the 10-yard line or even the 5-yard line. Some states use a “kicking” overtime where teams alternate field goal attempts. The NCAA’s format is considered the most balanced because it gives both teams a full possession from a reasonable distance.

There have been proposals to change the college overtime rules further, such as moving the starting position back or using a “shootout” style from the start, but the current system has remained largely unchanged since 1996, with the two-point conversion rule added in 2019 to shorten games.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a college football game end in a tie?

No, not since 1996. The overtime system ensures a winner. If the game is tied after regulation, they go to overtime. The only exception is if the game is called off due to weather or other circumstances before a winner is determined, but that’s rare.

What happens if the defense scores in overtime?

If the defense intercepts a pass or recovers a fumble and returns it for a touchdown, the game ends immediately. The defense wins because they have scored more points than the offense can possibly score on that possession. This is a sudden-death scenario within the possession.

How many overtimes can there be?

There is no limit. The game continues until one team is ahead after a complete overtime period (or after a two-point conversion attempt in the third overtime and beyond). The longest college football game in history had multiple overtimes, but the exact number is not officially recorded in a simple way. The rules allow for unlimited periods.

Why do teams have to go for two points in the second overtime?

This rule was introduced to speed up the game. In the first overtime, a team can kick an extra point, but starting in the second overtime, they must attempt a two-point conversion. This makes the game more exciting and reduces the number of possessions needed to decide a winner.

Does the team that wins the coin toss have an advantage?

Statistically, no. Because both teams get a possession, the coin toss winner doesn’t have a significant advantage. The only advantage is psychological – some teams prefer to know what they need to do. But the format is designed to be fair.

Sources: NCAA. Menus and buttons can differ slightly by version. Spotted something out of date? Tell us.